Criminal law blog, Edinburgh, Scotland

We are highly regarded Edinburgh Solicitors & Legal Aid lawyers specialising in all types of criminal defence, from road traffic offences to extradition.

Contact us now for a free initial consultation:
0131 557 9151

Lord Advocate to refer Five Cadder Cases to Supreme Court

The Lord Advocate is to refer five cases to the UK Supreme Court for a further ruling as to the scope of the Cadder v HMA decision which was handed down by last October by the Supreme Court.

Exercising her power under Schedule 6 to the Scotland Act 1998, the Lord Advocate Elish Angiolini QC is to ask the High Court referring the five cases in order to clarify the scope of Cadder v HMA. Cadder was a landmark case for criminal law in Scotland with a significant impact on criminal defence lawyers in Edinburgh and elsewhere in Scotland. The seven judge bench at the Supreme Court held in 2010 that the practice of detaining and interviewing a suspect without immediate access to a solicitor constitutes a breach of the right to a fair trial under Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights. Since then, there have been at least 867 prosecutions which have been unable to proceed as a direct result of Cadder, the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service ("COPFS") announced.

The referral of the five cases to the Supreme Court is aimed at clarifying the scope of the Cadder ruling, including whether incriminating statements made by a detained suspect against a co-accused are still inadmissible as evidence and whether information is inadmissible if it is given during roadside interview where the incident relates to a non-road traffic law matter.

Despite almost 900 cases having been dropped by the Crown as a direct result of Cadder and with many more potentially being unable to proceed to trial, the Supreme Court's clarification is not to be expected until at least October 2011, several months after Elish Angiolini QC will have stepped down as the Lord Advocate.

Further Scottish criminal appeals may be heard by ...

Related Posts

Comments

 
No comments made yet. Be the first to submit a comment
Already Registered? Login Here
Guest
Sunday, 25 October 2020

Get advice now | Fill in our enquiry form

First name (*)
Please let us know your name.

Last name (*)
Invalid Input

Email(*)
Please let us know your email address.

Telephone(*)
Please enter your phone number correctly.

Please tick the box below(*)
Invalid Input
Message(*)
Please let us know your message.

Services
Invalid Input

Contact Us

Call us today on 0131 557 9151 (24hrs) for a free, no
obligation discussion. Alternatively, request a
callback, email mcsporrans@aol.com 
or fill our our online enquiry form.

Where can you find us

Our solicitors, based in Edinburgh,
are ready to fight your corner.

McSporrans
45 Frederick Street
Edinburgh
EH2 1ES

twitter google-plus facebook google-plus

Need a Criminal Defence Lawyer?
Call us now on 0131 557 9151

McSporrans Criminal Lawyers Edinburgh Scotland